
Aphelion Review: A Beautiful Sci-Fi Story Held Back by Its Own Gameplay

Strengths
- A genuinely moving story about two astronauts fighting to reunite, carried by superb voice acting
- Persephone is a stunning place to explore, with icy vistas and a score that sells the isolation
- At 7 to 10 hours it respects your time and lands its ending without padding
Weaknesses
- Climbing and traversal grow repetitive, and the single quick-time event is used far too often
- Stealth sections feel uneven and checkpoints can turn tension into frustration
- Minor graphical glitches and a mixed critical reception show the rough edges
How we score: this verdict is our editorial take, based on launch coverage, critical reception and community feedback.
Aphelion is the kind of game that makes you wish the controller felt as good as the story reads. DON'T NOD's sci-fi adventure, which arrived on Game Pass on November 17 after launching in April, tells a genuinely moving story about two astronauts trying to find each other on a hostile alien planet. It looks stunning, it sounds superb, and then it asks you to climb the same icy wall for the fifth time. This Aphelion review scores it 6.5 out of 10: a beautiful game that keeps getting in its own way.
The setup is pure hard sci-fi. In 2062, humanity is on the brink, and two astronauts, Dr Ariane Montclair and Officer Thomas Cross, are sent to evaluate Persephone, a newly discovered ninth planet, as a possible new home. Their ship crashes. Ariane walks away mostly unhurt. Thomas is left near fatally wounded with his oxygen running down. The two of them have to cross a frozen world to reunite, and the game splits your time between them.
Aphelion Review: The Story Works, the Gameplay Stumbles
Start with what works, because a lot works. The story is brilliantly written, with a relationship at its center that actually earns its emotional beats. Ariane and Thomas are not action heroes. They are scared, tired people trying to stay alive, and the voice work from Vanessa Dolmen and Eric Geynes sells every bit of it. The ending lands. Several critics called it cathartic, and that is fair.
The presentation is the other big win. Persephone is a gorgeous, lonely place: vast glacial plains, dark ice caves, storms rolling across the horizon. DON'T NOD built the game with input from the actual European Space Agency, and the grounded, realistic tech shows in every detail. Composer Amine Bouhafa's score does the rest, carrying the quiet stretches and swelling at exactly the right moments. As a piece of science fiction, Aphelion is genuinely impressive.
The problem is the game part. Traversal is the main mechanic, and it is the weakest part of the package. Climbing is repetitive and sometimes imprecise, stealth sections drag on and feel inconsistent, and the game leans on a single quick-time event so often that it becomes a running joke. None of this is broken. It is just dated, the kind of design that felt old on the PS3, let alone the PS5.
Two Astronauts, One Broken Planet
The split structure is the smartest thing about the design. Ariane gets the exploration and the action. Thomas gets the quieter, tenser half: short bursts of movement between oxygen supplies, environmental puzzles, and the constant pressure of a depleting tank. When the game slows down and lets the two of them talk, it is at its best.
That structure also exposes the padding. The runtime is roughly 7 to 10 hours depending on how much you explore, and the back half is stronger than the front. Once you pass the midpoint, the story takes over and the game becomes hard to put down. Getting there takes patience, especially through the early climbing stretches that teach you everything you need to know and then keep teaching it.
Technical issues do not help. Critics reported minor graphical glitches, awkward checkpoints, and occasional moments where the game simply refuses to tell you where to go. A launch patch was promised, and the Game Pass version benefits from months of fixes, but the rough edges are still visible if you look for them.
What the Critics Said
The critical reception tells the same story as this verdict. Aphelion sits at 64 to 65 on Metacritic, firmly in mixed territory, with only about a third of critics recommending it on OpenCritic. The split is not about the story. Almost everyone agrees the writing, the performances and the world are strong. The split is about whether the gameplay is good enough to carry them, and a lot of reviewers decided it was not.
That is the honest tension of this game. The people who love it really love it, and the people who bounced off it did so for concrete reasons, not taste. Both sides are right. Aphelion is a better movie than it is a game, and DON'T NOD's strengths have always been narrative. Here, the narrative carries a game that was never quite finished in the same way.
The Verdict
So is Aphelion worth your time now that it is on Game Pass? Yes, with the right expectations. If you like slow, thoughtful science fiction in the vein of Interstellar or Project Hail Mary, and you can tolerate repetitive traversal to get to a great story, this is an easy recommendation. It costs you nothing but a download if you already subscribe, and the ending is worth the trip.
If you want tight mechanics and a game that respects every minute of your time, you will struggle. The climbing, the stealth and the quick-time events are real weaknesses, and they do not go away. Aphelion is a 6.5: a flawed, beautiful, frustrating game that is worth playing for its story alone, as long as you know what you are signing up for. Read our Aphelion Game Pass arrival story for the full details on the November 17 drop, and check the Game Pass November wave 2 lineup to see what else landed alongside it. The game is available now on PC, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and S, and on Game Pass. The official Steam page has the full store listing.

